Problems encountered in conventional HIV 1/2 Algorithms: lack of necessity for immunoblot assays to confirm repeated ELISA reactive results
AFRICAN HEALTH SCIENCES
Authors: Yuksel, Pelin; Saribas, Suat; Kuskucu, Mert; Mutcali, Sibel Islak; Kosan, Erdogan; Habip, Zafer; Demirci, Mehmet; Kara, Eda Salihoglu; Birinci, Ilhan; Caliskan, Reyhan; Dinc, Harika Oyku; Midilli, Kenan; Ziver, Tevhide; Kocazeybek, Bekir
Abstract
Background: The use of conventional (serologically based) HIV 1/2 diagnostic algorithms has become controversial in recent years. Objectives: Sera from patients who underwent verification tests were evaluated because repeated ELISA-reactive results demonstrated a HIV1+HIV2 positive band pattern. Methods: The line immunoassay (LIA) test was used for repeated HIV enzyme immunoassays (EIA)-reactive sera in patients at three centers. The Bio-Rad Geenius T HIV 1/2 and the HIV-1 RNA tests were used. HIV-1 and RNA HIV-2 were investigated using PCR. Results: LIA was used to evaluate 3,224 out of 10,591 samples with repeated ELISA reactivity (30%). We found that 32 (1%) of the sera, along with HIV1 bands and HIV2 gp36 bands, were positive. Only 28 of the 32 verified serum samples with gp36 bands were repeated, and no gp36 band positivity was detected using the Bio-Rad Geenius T HIV-1/2 confirmatory assay in these serum samples. The HIV-2 proviral DNAs were also negative. Therefore, we excluded the possibility of HIV1+2 co-infection. All samples from the 32 patients were positive for HIV-1 RNA. Conclusion: Our findings highlight the need to exclude confirmatory tests like the LIA test from the current diagnostic HIV algorithm and replace it with rapid HIV-1 and HIV-2 confirmatory immunochromotographic tests.
Strongly enhanced sensitivity of a direct anti-HIV-1/-2 assay in seroconversion by incorporation of HIV p24 ag detection: a new generation vironostika HIV Uni-Form II
JOURNAL OF VIROLOGICAL METHODS
Authors: van Binsbergen, J; Keur, W; Siebelink, A; van de Graaf, M; Jacobs, A; de Rijk, D; Nijholt, L; Toonen, J; Gurtler, LG
Abstract
The clinical sensitivity of the current anti-HIV assays is based for an important part on their reactivity with seroconversion panels. The most sensitive assay closes the seroconversion window as much as possible, thereby reducing the risk of transmitting false negative donations obtained from individuals infected recently. Because of the absence of anti-HIV antibodies during the early phase of infection, the seroconversion window can be narrowed partially by detection of HIV p24 Ag. To achieve this, the highest affinity anti-p24 binding antibodies were selected with BIAcore(TM) and applied in a direct assay format. To achieve optimal conditions for the anti-HIV part of the assay the HIV specific antigens Viral HIV-1 gp160, HIV-2 gp36 and HIV-I group O gp41 peptides were used. These antigens and antibodies were applied for microELISA coating as well as in the conjugate pearl, which is present in the well of the microELISA plate. The (analytical) anti-HIV-1/-2 and anti-HIV-l group O sensitivity of this new assay, Vironostika HIV Uni-Form II Ag/Ab, is at least at the level of the current Vironostika HIV Uni-Form II plus O. When compared to the Vironostika HIV Uni-Form II plus O, the seroconversion window is narrowed by 1-2 weeks due to the incorporation of HIV p24 Ag detection. The level of reactivity of the anti-HIV and HIV Ag detection part can be improved by about a factor 2 by applying continuous shaking during sample incubation. Initial studies suggested that the specificity of the assay is identical to that of the Vironostika HIV Uni-Form II plus O, namely > 99.9%. Monitoring of proper execution of the assay handling steps was facilitated by implementing a purple dye in the conjugate pearl. Colourless specimen diluent changes into a green fluid upon dissolving of the conjugate pearl and turns subsequently into blue/purple upon sample addition. These visual changes can also be determined by spectrophotometric measurement at 620 nm. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.