Adrenal Metastases as Sanctuary Sites in Advanced Renal Cancer
JOURNAL OF KIDNEY CANCER AND VHL
Authors: Vaishampayan, Ulka; Shah, Harsh; Asad, Mohammad F.; Shi, Dongping; Dickow, Brenda; Suisham, Stacey; Domina, Jason; Cher, Michael L.; Samantray, Julie; Aoun, Hussein D.
Abstract
Involvement of the adrenal gland in kidney cancer represents a unique site of metastasis with a distinct clinical course. The cases are typically resistant to immune therapy and need local therapy management. A case series of patients with adrenal metastases was reviewed to highlight the nuances of clinical course and therapy. We reviewed renal cancer carcinoma (RCC) cases with adrenal metastases at Karmanos Cancer Center, Detroit MI. Medical records were reviewed to collect relevant case information. Next-generation sequencing, tumor mutation burden testing, and programmed death ligand biomarkers were evaluated in five cases. Twelve cases were reviewed; all were males with a median age of 49.5 years. Three patients presented with adrenal metastases only and were treated with local therapy. Three received interleukin-2 (IL-2). One patient relapsed with bilateral adrenal lesions after 11 years of remission, post-IL-2 therapy. Five cases received immune checkpoint inhibitor (ICI) and one received antivascular therapy. ICI therapy was followed by ablation of residual adrenal metastases in three patients. Genomic profiling was available in five cases. All were BAP1 and PD-L1 negative.Pathogenic mutations in PBRM1, SETD2, and VHL were noted. All patients with residual adrenal metastases responded to antivascular therapies or to local ablation. One patient died 17 years after diagnosis and 11 patients are alive at a median follow-up of 9.5 years. Adrenal metastases in RCC have a distinct clinical course. They can represent a sanctuary site of relapse/ residual disease following treatment with immune therapy. Management with local therapy can induce durable remissions. Systemic management with antivascular therapies also demonstrated favorable responses. Further investigation should focus on the unique clinical course and optimal management of adrenal metastases in kidney cancer.
HIF-1 alpha and HIF-2 alpha differently regulate tumour development and inflammation of clear cell renal cell carcinoma in mice
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS
Authors: Hoefflin, Rouven; Harlander, Sabine; Schaefer, Silvia; Metzger, Patrick; Kuo, Fengshen; Schoenenberger, Desiree; Adlesic, Mojca; Peighambari, Asin; Seidel, Philipp; Chen, Chia-yi; Consenza-Contreras, Miguel; Jud, Andreas; Lahrmann, Bernd; Grabe, Niels; Heide, Danijela; Uhl, Franziska M.; Chan, Timothy A.; Duyster, Justus; Zeiser, Robert; Schell, Christoph; Heikenwalder, Mathias; Schilling, Oliver; Hakimi, A. Ari; Boerries, Melanie; Frew, Ian J.
Abstract
Mutational inactivation of VHL is the earliest genetic event in the majority of clear cell renal cell carcinomas (ccRCC), leading to accumulation of the HIF-1 alpha and HIF-2 alpha transcription factors. While correlative studies of human ccRCC and functional studies using human ccRCC cell lines have implicated HIF-1 alpha as an inhibitor and HIF-2 alpha as a promoter of aggressive tumour behaviours, their roles in tumour onset have not been functionally addressed. Herein we show using an autochthonous ccRCC model that Hif1a is essential for tumour formation whereas Hif2a deletion has only minor effects on tumour initiation and growth. Both HIF-1 alpha and HIF-2 alpha are required for the clear cell phenotype. Transcriptomic and proteomic analyses reveal that HIF-1 alpha regulates glycolysis while HIF-2 alpha regulates genes associated with lipoprotein metabolism, ribosome biogenesis and E2F and MYC transcriptional activities. HIF-2 alpha -deficient tumours are characterised by increased antigen presentation, interferon signalling and CD8(+) T cell infiltration and activation. Single copy loss of HIF1A or high levels of HIF2A mRNA expression correlate with altered immune microenvironments in human ccRCC. These studies reveal an oncogenic role of HIF-1 alpha in ccRCC initiation and suggest that alterations in the balance of HIF-1 alpha and HIF-2 alpha activities can affect different aspects of ccRCC biology and disease aggressiveness. Genetic inactivation of VHL leads to stabilization of HIF-1 alpha /HIF-2 alpha and is associated with clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) initiation and progression. Using an autochthonous mouse model of ccRCC with Vhl deletion, here the authors show that HIF-1 alpha is necessary for tumor formation, while HIF-2 alpha deletion has only a moderate effect.